Perps: Quanto > Traditional?

Quanto Perpetual Futures vs Traditional Perpetual Futures: an overview of the what, why, and how

Both quanto and traditional perpetual futures let traders speculate on an index asset by posting collateral to secure the position. The difference is the numeraire: the asset in which profits and losses are settled. Traditional perps settle PnL in the quote asset, typically USD. Quanto (quantity-adjusting) perps settle PnL in a numeraire that differs from the quote asset, using an exchange rate fixed at the position's onset. This piece explains the mechanics, purpose, and distinctions, then steps through two detailed trade lifecycle examples that make the payoff math, and the significance of units, explicit.

1. What

Both derivatives enable traders to speculate on an index asset by posting some collateral asset to secure the position. However, the numeraire asset used for settling payouts varies between markets.

Quanto perps uniquely allow traders' profits and losses (PnL) to be settled in a numeraire asset that differs from the quote asset, which is used to express or price the index asset. Typically, this quote asset for any index asset is USD in both traditional and quanto perps.

Asset Roles

Four distinct roles appear in every perp market. In traditional perps, two or three of them are played by the same asset, which is why the distinctions are easy to miss. Quanto perps force the roles apart.

Role Definition
Collateral Asset The asset used as security by the holder of the derivative to enter into the contract.
Index Asset The underlying asset that the derivative contract is based on, whose price movement the derivative aims to track or derive value from.
Numeraire Asset The currency in which the derivative's payouts are denominated or settled.
Quote Asset The asset in which the index asset's value is expressed or priced. Typically, this is USD.

Table 1: The four asset roles in a perp market.

Reading a market spec: a BTC perp can be quoted in USD (the price on screen is $/BTC), collateralized in ETH (the trader posts ETH margin), and settled in either USD (traditional) or ETH (quanto). The first two choices are common. It is the third, the numeraire, that separates quanto from traditional.

2. Why

While trading traditional perps, traders face exchange rate risk if the quote asset used to price the index asset weakens. Furthermore, even multi-collateral supported traditional perps do not provide full protection against exchange rate risk.

For example, if a position in a traditional perps market still settles PnL in a quote asset numeraire, weakening of the quote asset affects the index-derived PnL return.

Why multi-collateral is not enough: posting ETH as margin hedges only the collateral leg. The ETH margin appreciates if ETH rises, but the index-derived PnL leg is still denominated in the quote asset. A trader who wins $20,000 on a BTC long receives $20,000 of quote-asset value, regardless of how far the quote asset has slid against the assets the trader actually wants to hold. Section 5 quantifies exactly this effect.

Quanto perps fix this problem, and more.

3. How

The central innovation of the quantity-adjusting (“quanto”) derivative is its ability to adjust for changes in the value of the quote asset. If the quote asset weakens, the derivative adjusts the quantity of the numeraire asset that the quote asset can be exchanged for, to match the numeraire-to-quote exchange rate established at the position's onset.

This adjustment mechanism preserves PnL in terms of the numeraire, regardless of fluctuations in the exchange rate between the numeraire and quote asset during the position's lifetime.

The Quanto Factor

At the moment a trader enters a quanto perps position, the exchange rate between the numeraire (e.g., ETH) and the quote asset (USD) is locked in. This fixed exchange rate is what Kwenta (KIP-117) terms the “Quanto Factor.”

Let \(X\) denote the numeraire's own quote-asset price (USD per ETH). The quanto factor is the entry conversion rate from quote to numeraire:

$$f_q = \frac{1}{X_{\text{entry}}} \qquad \left[\frac{\text{ETH}}{\text{USD}}\right]$$

The locked rate is critical because it is used to calculate PnL in the numeraire currency, irrespective of subsequent fluctuations in the actual market exchange rate between the numeraire and the quote asset.

Interpretation: a traditional perp says “you won $20,000, paid in dollars.” A quanto perp says “you won $20,000, paid in ETH at the price ETH was when you opened.” If ETH was $4,000 at entry, the payout is 5 ETH, even if ETH trades at $5,000 by the time the position closes. The trader's index-derived PnL is preserved in numeraire terms, and any appreciation of the numeraire accrues on top.

4. Payoff Math and Units

The content so far might be a tough read if you are new to perps, quanto derivatives, or DeFi. The remainder of this piece breaks the “what, why, and how” down further by stepping through two detailed trade lifecycle examples, explaining the basic math behind the payoffs, and emphasizing the significance of units (see User-Defined Types in DeFi and Why You Should Care).

Notation

Symbol Name Unit
\(P\) Index price USD per index unit
\(N\) Position size Index units
\(X\) Numeraire / collateral price USD per ETH
\(M\) Position margin ETH

Table 2: Symbols used in the payoff formulas. In both examples the collateral is ETH; in the quanto market the numeraire is also ETH.

Traditional Perps (numeraire = quote = USD)

A traditional market computes index-derived PnL and collateral-derived PnL directly in the quote asset:

$$\text{PnL}_{\text{index}} = \underbrace{(P_{\text{exit}} - P_{\text{entry}})}_{\Delta\text{ index price}} \times N \qquad [\text{USD}]$$
$$\text{PnL}_{\text{collateral}} = \underbrace{(X_{\text{exit}} - X_{\text{entry}})}_{\Delta\text{ collateral price}} \times M \qquad [\text{USD}]$$
$$\text{Total PnL} = \text{PnL}_{\text{index}} + \text{PnL}_{\text{collateral}} \qquad [\text{USD}]$$

The trader's total margin after the trade is the index-derived PnL plus the position margin, valued at exit:

$$\text{Total Margin} = \text{PnL}_{\text{index}} + M \times X_{\text{exit}} \qquad [\text{USD}]$$

Quanto Perps (numeraire = ETH, quote = USD)

A quanto market applies the quanto factor, the entry USD:ETH exchange rate, to the index-derived PnL, settling it in ETH:

$$\text{PnL}_{\text{index}} = (P_{\text{exit}} - P_{\text{entry}}) \times N \times \frac{1}{X_{\text{entry}}} \qquad [\text{ETH}]$$

The units justify the name quantity-adjusting. The quote-asset PnL is converted into a quantity of numeraire at a fixed rate:

$$\frac{\text{USD}}{\text{BTC}} \times \text{BTC} \times \frac{\text{ETH}}{\text{USD}} = \text{ETH}$$

The trader's margin is ETH held in kind, so its ETH-denominated quantity never changes. Its USD-denominated gain can still be expressed in ETH by converting at the exit rate:

$$\text{PnL}_{\text{collateral}} = (X_{\text{exit}} - X_{\text{entry}}) \times M \times \frac{1}{X_{\text{exit}}} \qquad [\text{ETH}]$$
$$\text{Total PnL} = \text{PnL}_{\text{index}} + \text{PnL}_{\text{collateral}} \qquad [\text{ETH}]$$
$$\text{Total Margin} = \text{PnL}_{\text{index}} + M \qquad [\text{ETH}]$$
Why two different rates? Only the index leg is settled by the market, and it uses the locked entry rate: that is the quanto factor at work. The collateral line is bookkeeping on the trader's own ETH: it re-expresses the margin's USD appreciation in ETH at the exit rate, so that “Total PnL” times \(X_{\text{exit}}\) equals the total USD equity gain. Both conventions are internally consistent, and the worked examples below verify this: exit margin value minus entry margin value equals Total PnL valued at exit, in both markets.

5. Trade Lifecycle, Example A

A trader deposits 3 ETH of collateral and opens a 2 BTC long position (10x leverage), in two otherwise-identical markets:

Role Synthetix v3 Multi-Collateral Perps Kwenta Quanto Perps
Collateral ETH ETH
Index BTC BTC
Numeraire USD ETH
Quote USD USD

Table 3: Example A market configuration. The only difference is the numeraire.

Example A: Given State
  • Collateral deposited: \(M = 3\) ETH
  • Position: long \(N = 2\) BTC
  • At entry: \(1\) ETH \(= \$4{,}000\), \(1\) BTC \(= \$60{,}000\)
  • At exit: \(1\) ETH \(= \$5{,}000\), \(1\) BTC \(= \$70{,}000\)

Leverage check: notional \(= 2 \times \$60{,}000 = \$120{,}000\) against \(3 \times \$4{,}000 = \$12{,}000\) of margin \(\Rightarrow\) 10x.

Traditional: Synthetix v3 Multi-Collateral

Index-derived PnL and collateral-derived PnL sum to total PnL, all in USD:

$$\underbrace{\left(\frac{\$70{,}000}{\text{BTC}} - \frac{\$60{,}000}{\text{BTC}}\right) \times 2\,\text{BTC}}_{\text{index derived}} + \underbrace{\left(\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} - \frac{\$4{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) \times 3\,\text{ETH}}_{\text{collateral derived}} = \$20{,}000 + \$3{,}000 = \boxed{\$23{,}000}$$

Total margin after the trade, index-derived PnL plus the position margin valued at exit:

$$\$20{,}000 + \left(3\,\text{ETH} \times \frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) = \boxed{\$35{,}000}$$

Quanto: Kwenta

The index-derived PnL is multiplied by the quanto factor, the entry USD:ETH exchange rate, and settles in ETH. The collateral's USD gain is expressed in ETH at exit:

$$\underbrace{\left(\frac{\$70{,}000}{\text{BTC}} - \frac{\$60{,}000}{\text{BTC}}\right) \times 2\,\text{BTC} \times \frac{\text{ETH}}{\$4{,}000}}_{\text{index derived}\;=\;5\,\text{ETH}} + \underbrace{\left(\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} - \frac{\$4{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) \times 3\,\text{ETH} \times \frac{\text{ETH}}{\$5{,}000}}_{\text{collateral derived}\;=\;0.6\,\text{ETH}} = \boxed{5.6\,\text{ETH}}$$

Valued at exit:

$$\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} \times 5.6\,\text{ETH} = \boxed{\$28{,}000}$$

Total margin after the trade, index-derived PnL plus the position margin, both already in ETH:

$$5\,\text{ETH} + 3\,\text{ETH} = \boxed{8\,\text{ETH}} \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad \frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} \times 8\,\text{ETH} = \boxed{\$40{,}000}$$
Same trade, different settlement: both traders were long 2 BTC through the same $10,000 move. The traditional trader exits with $35,000 of margin. The quanto trader exits with 8 ETH \(= \$40{,}000\). The extra $5,000 is the 5 ETH of index-derived PnL appreciating from $4,000 to $5,000 per ETH: PnL was preserved in the numeraire, and the numeraire itself rallied.

6. Trade Lifecycle, Example B

Now the trader deposits 3 ETH of collateral and opens a 6 ETH long position (2x leverage). The index asset and the collateral asset are both ETH, so in the quanto market a single asset plays three roles: collateral, index, and numeraire.

Role Synthetix v3 Multi-Collateral Perps Kwenta Quanto Perps
Collateral ETH ETH
Index ETH ETH
Numeraire USD ETH
Quote USD USD

Table 4: Example B market configuration.

Example B: Given State
  • Collateral deposited: \(M = 3\) ETH
  • Position: long \(N = 6\) ETH
  • At entry: \(1\) ETH \(= \$4{,}000\)
  • At exit: \(1\) ETH \(= \$5{,}000\)

Leverage check: notional \(= 6 \times \$4{,}000 = \$24{,}000\) against \(\$12{,}000\) of margin \(\Rightarrow\) 2x.

Traditional: Synthetix v3 Multi-Collateral

$$\underbrace{\left(\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} - \frac{\$4{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) \times 6\,\text{ETH}}_{\text{index derived}} + \underbrace{\left(\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} - \frac{\$4{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) \times 3\,\text{ETH}}_{\text{collateral derived}} = \$6{,}000 + \$3{,}000 = \boxed{\$9{,}000}$$

Total margin after the trade:

$$\$6{,}000 + \left(3\,\text{ETH} \times \frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) = \boxed{\$21{,}000}$$

Quanto: Kwenta

$$\underbrace{\left(\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} - \frac{\$4{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) \times 6\,\text{ETH} \times \frac{\text{ETH}}{\$4{,}000}}_{\text{index derived}\;=\;1.5\,\text{ETH}} + \underbrace{\left(\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} - \frac{\$4{,}000}{\text{ETH}}\right) \times 3\,\text{ETH} \times \frac{\text{ETH}}{\$5{,}000}}_{\text{collateral derived}\;=\;0.6\,\text{ETH}} = \boxed{2.1\,\text{ETH}}$$

Valued at exit:

$$\frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} \times 2.1\,\text{ETH} = \boxed{\$10{,}500}$$

Total margin after the trade:

$$1.5\,\text{ETH} + 3\,\text{ETH} = \boxed{4.5\,\text{ETH}} \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad \frac{\$5{,}000}{\text{ETH}} \times 4.5\,\text{ETH} = \boxed{\$22{,}500}$$
ETH-on-ETH compounding: when the index and the numeraire are the same rising asset, the quanto payoff is effectively convex in that asset: the position wins in ETH terms and each ETH of winnings is worth more USD. The traditional trader books $9,000; the quanto trader books 2.1 ETH \(= \$10{,}500\).

7. Bonus

Establishing a fixed numeraire-to-quote exchange rate can have a “degen-welcomed” side effect when both the numeraire and index assets increase in value. Greater profits are achieved when PnL is calculated using the numeraire at a favorable exchange rate, as opposed to holding a similar position in traditional perpetual contracts.

The advantage decomposes cleanly: it is the index-derived PnL, already fixed in numeraire units by the quanto factor, multiplied by the numeraire's appreciation over the position's lifetime:

$$\text{Quanto Advantage} = \underbrace{(P_{\text{exit}} - P_{\text{entry}}) \times N \times \frac{1}{X_{\text{entry}}}}_{\text{index PnL in numeraire}} \times\; (X_{\text{exit}} - X_{\text{entry}}) \qquad [\text{USD}]$$
Example Index PnL (ETH) ETH Appreciation Quanto Advantage
A: 2 BTC long 5 ETH $1,000 $5,000 \((= \$40{,}000 - \$35{,}000)\)
B: 6 ETH long 1.5 ETH $1,000 $1,500 \((= \$22{,}500 - \$21{,}000)\)

Table 5: The quanto advantage in each worked example.

The mirror image: the same mechanism cuts the other way. If the numeraire weakens against the quote asset while the index rises, the quanto trader's index-derived PnL, fixed in numeraire units, is worth less in USD terms than a traditional trader's USD-settled PnL. Quanto settlement preserves PnL in the numeraire, not in USD. Whether that is a feature or a risk depends entirely on which asset the trader wants exposure to, which is precisely the point.

8. Summary

Dimension Traditional Perps Quanto Perps
Settlement numeraire Quote asset (typically USD) Non-quote asset (e.g., ETH)
Index PnL conversion None; already in quote terms Fixed at entry via the quanto factor \(1/X_{\text{entry}}\)
Quote-asset weakness Erodes index-derived PnL's real value PnL preserved in numeraire terms
Numeraire + index both rally No extra benefit Amplified USD-value profits
Numeraire weakens, index rallies USD-settled PnL unaffected PnL worth less in USD terms

Table 6: Traditional vs quanto perps at a glance.

Traditional and quanto perps price the same index and can accept the same collateral. The entire difference, and every number in the examples above, follows from one design decision: which asset plays the numeraire, and at what exchange rate the quote-asset PnL is converted into it. Getting the units right is not pedantry; it is the product.

References

  1. Kwenta. KIP-117: Quanto Perpetual Futures Market. gov.kwenta.eth.limo/kips/kip-117.
  2. Synthetix. Synthetix v3 Perpetual Futures Markets. github.com/Synthetixio/synthetix-v3.
  3. Kwenta. Quanto Dimensions: a user-defined type system for quanto market units. github.com/Kwenta/quanto-dimensions.
  4. Harper, T. Quanto Units. github.com/tommyrharper/shared-notes.
  5. Borders, J. (2024). User-Defined Types in DeFi and Why You Should Care. /pieces/user-defined-types-in-defi.